Below are all of the homes in Cicero Shores subdivision/neighborhood, Cicero, Indiana currently for sale, pending or sold within the last 6 months.

Enter your email address in the yellow box below if you would like to receive an automated email that will update you every time any central Indiana REALTOR® at any real estate company lists, pends or sells a home in Cicero Shores.

Cicero Shores Homes for Sale & Sold in Cicero

Close [x]
Name this search: 
 
 
1289 S Bayswater Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

1289 S Bayswater Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Live the wonderful lake life. Great view of morse lake. Deeded boat slip - right across from this fantastic home. $200. 00 dues per yr includes dock and deck overlooking the lake. Inside is an updated kitchen, living room, and separate family room. 25x24 wood deck in backyard. Great fireplace in family room. 4 bedrooms - 2 master bedrooms. A must see.

MLS/BLC #21786982 is a 4-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1980 and offers 1686 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1686, main floor 1146, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

South on main street in cicero, 1 mile to bayswater, turn right, home is on left

4 Beds 3 Bath Areas 1686 SqFt

$434,900

(Home for Sale)

RE/MAX Ability Plus
Time on M.S.Woods: 24 Days
549 S Iron Bridge Road, Cicero, IN 46034

549 S Iron Bridge Road, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

You won't find many like this one. These homeowners have done all the work leaving the next owners lots of time to enjoy the fruits of their labor. So much to enjoy we can't list them all but here are a few highlights. Beautiful landscaping and mature trees, covered back deck for entertaining and beautiful covered front porch for watching the sunset, 2 car garage with large workshop and 1 car garage (for your must have if you live in cicero) golf cart, completely remodeled home inside and out , low traffic on this cul-de-sac street, close enough to all the restaurants and amenities this lake town has to offer that you may only drive your car in the winter. Fantastic hh school system.

MLS/BLC #21788748 is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1978 and offers 1000 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1000, main floor 1000, basement 0 and 264 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sale Pending"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

State road 19 to park st turn west to iron bridge turn right to the home on the right.

2 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1000 SqFt

$249,900

(Sale Pending)

CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Time on M.S.Woods: 10 Days
2570 E Sheridan Court, Cicero, IN 46034

2570 E Sheridan Court, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Cute three bed/two bath ranch home nestled in wooded cul-de-sac. Many upgrades, including painted woodwork, vinyl plank kitchen flooring & foyer, ss appliances, granite countertops, new tub/sink/flooring in 2nd bath, new shower/sink/flooring in master bath. Master suite patio doors & kitchen doors lead out to covered wooden deck. Most windows replaced in oct 2011 with transferable warranty. Furnace/hvac replaced 2014. Lots of privacy. Backyard has a shed (shed is sold as-is) and chain length fence (property goes back further than fence). Schedule showings at least 30 min in advance.

MLS/BLC #21778420 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1988 and offers 1436 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1436, main floor 1436, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.

North on 37, west on 206th street to hague rd / stringtown pike, north to lincoln, east to sheridan.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1436 SqFt

$250,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 44 Days
1340 W Beachway Court, Cicero, IN 46034

1340 W Beachway Court, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Popular lake community in cicero. This 3 bedroom 2 full bath ranch sits on large corner lot just steps away from the lake. Step inside to a large family room w/a gorgeous wood burning fireplace. Mbr has double closets and full bath. Kitchen includes all appliances and washer & dryer stay too. Walk out on the covered back patio. Fully fenced backyard. Backyard also has a firepit for cozy evenings. Insulated garage with heater. New ac in 2020, new firepit and some of the fence is new.

MLS/BLC #21778508 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1976 and offers 1199 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1199, main floor 1199, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

North on hague road from sr 38 in noblesville. Hague turns into stringtown pike, keep heading north on stringtown to beachway court on left.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1199 SqFt

$200,000

(Sold)

Carpenter, REALTORS®
Time on M.S.Woods: 59 Days
210 E Bayshore Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

210 E Bayshore Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Live like you are on vacation every day. This serene lake house is the perfect getaway or could be the most relaxing daily lifestyle you have experienced. This cute ranch boasts 3 bedrooms and 1 and half bathrooms with updates everywhere. Kitchen has been recently updated with beautiful natural wood cabinetry and stone countertops. Appliances have been updated to stainless steel. Fresh paint in many areas with gorgeous flooring thru all of the main areas. But the best part of the house is the 3 tier deck leading to your own boat dock where you will spend most of your time here. Back yard has a firepit, grill, privacy fence, and another open patio off the back of the house. Don't miss this opportunity to have your own oasis in cicero.

MLS/BLC #21777005 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1972 and offers 1256 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1256, main floor 1256, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

From highway 19 north through cicero to bayshore drive to home on right.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1256 SqFt

$372,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 66 Days
1120 N Stringtown Pike, Cicero, IN 46034

1120 N Stringtown Pike, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Location, location, location, near park, walking path & morse lake. Stunning 2 br, 2 bath, w/so many upgrades. Solid 8 panel cherry wood doors, trim & baseboards & upgraded lighting throughout. Luxury kitchen w/stainless steel professional appliances, solid surface countertops, solid 42” cherry wood cabinets w/pullouts. Bathrooms boast solid surfaces and cherry wood vanities, upper cabinets & brushed nickel fixtures. Bedrooms with 3/4” hand scraped maple hardwood floors. Upscale double cell bali blinds throughout home. Finished & insulated garage. Added bonus office in garage with 3/4" hickory scraped flooring. 14x12 screened porch & paver patio, 18x12 barn w/double doors, mature trees in large backyard. A must see. . .

MLS/BLC #21770524 is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1975 and offers 1296 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1296, main floor 1296, basement 0 and 528 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

From noblesville, n on sr 19 to brinton (at marathon). Left on brinton to stringtown pike, left to home on right.

2 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1296 SqFt

$260,000

(Sold)

Keller Williams Indy Metro NE
Time on M.S.Woods: 87 Days
1589 N Overlook Circle, Cicero, IN 46034

1589 N Overlook Circle, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Must see this wonderful home in the heart of cicero. A meticulously maintained home has a split level floor plan - the main level has a cozy living room with fireplace and eat-in kitchen with great views of the spacious and open back yard. The lower level has a bonus room, half bath, and laundry room. The upper level has a large master br, full bath, and secondary bedrooms. Great lot with mature trees, a storage barn, concrete patio, and a beautiful backyard. Recent updates include new water heater, newer roof 2018, siding, windows, and gutters. Amazing location as your a "stone's throw" away from morse lake and all things cicero.

MLS/BLC #21770723 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1980 and offers 1604 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1110, main floor 494, basement 615 and 312 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

From 216th st - head north on stringtown pike to overlook and turn left.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1604 SqFt

$215,000

(Sold)

CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Time on M.S.Woods: 94 Days
1429 W Lighthouse Point, Cicero, IN 46034

1429 W Lighthouse Point, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Wow. Check out this amazing 4 bedroom, 2. 5 bath home with deep water frontage on morse lake. Covered boat lift and dock is included in sale with an updated galvanized steel seawall on main body of lake. Enjoy fun summer nights relaxing around the in-ground pool on back patio, new awning, and firepit. Kitchen has been updated with granite countertops, new walk in kitchen pantry, and stainless steel appliances. Newer carpet upstairs and newer ac unit. Large master suite to include double vanities, garden tub, separate shower, huge walk in closet and gas fireplace. Plenty of space in home with separate areas in loft, basement, great room, dining room and library/den.

MLS/BLC #21769044 is a 4-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1980 and offers 3678 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 3138, main floor 1376, basement 540 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

32 west of noblesville to hague rd. . Pass marina & continue to nantucket. Left to lighthouse pt. Home is on right.

4 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3678 SqFt

$450,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 104 Days
2410 E Lincoln Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

2410 E Lincoln Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Don't miss this 3 bedroom 2 1/2 bath home in a popular morse lake community. Enjoy your large fully fenced yard, relax or entertain on your huge deck/patio. Master includes walk-in closet, fully tile shower. Main level has a pretty open floor plan, brand new gas log fireplace and cathedral ceiling in the living room. Home also features new gutters equipped with top of the line gutter guards as well as updated pella windows. 1/89 ownership in the common lot located on the west side of stringtown pike across from the south entrance of lincoln drive. The common lot features large lot as well as lake access for fishing or swimming.

MLS/BLC #21767434 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1988 and offers 1759 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1759, main floor 910, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

Sr19 to 216th st, w to hague(stringtown pike)n to linclon-right to home or sr31 to 236th st-cross lake to 4 way stop(main)turn s, rd changes name to stringtown pike-proceed on to lincloln left to home.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 1759 SqFt

$249,900

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 116 Days
2480 W Stringtown Pike, Cicero, IN 46034

2480 W Stringtown Pike, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 bath home just a short walk to morse reservoir. Partially fenced backyard with a wall garden, raised beds and new shed to store everything. Beautiful plantings around the yard keep the garden lively from spring to fall. Over the last 12 months, owners have been busy. . . New windows, hot water heater, upgraded/new electrical panel, shed, new gutters with covers, bathroom tile and exterior paint, all for the new owners. . . Is it you? *bird condo included. Enjoy some of the homeowners' pictures from the seasons so you can see what the wonderful plantings look like in bloom.

MLS/BLC #21759349 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1978 and offers 1884 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1884, main floor 1884, basement 0 and 400 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

North on sr19 to 206 st. West to hague rd. North on hague which turns into stringtown pk-home on corner of stringtown & overlook on s/w corner

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1884 SqFt

$270,000

(Sold)

Keller Williams Indy Metro NE
Time on M.S.Woods: 158 Days
1582 N Bayswater Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

1582 N Bayswater Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

Subdivision: Cicero Shores

Add to Favorites

Fabulous cul-de-sac location on the main body of morse. This morse lake home features professional landscaping, vaulted ceilings with floor to ceiling windows, dining room, dual fireplaces, main floor laundry, large master suite w/enormous closet & bath & 3 car garage. Walk out lower level with living space, wet bar, bedroom, full bath and enclosed sun room. Walk out to flat backyard with lakeside patio perfect for evening sunset views over the lake. Newer u shaped dock with covered boat lift & jet ski port. Many newer mechanicals – hvac (2020), electrical box wiring (2018), water heater (2017), (seawall (2014).

MLS/BLC #21745853 is a 3-bedroom, 4-bath property located in Hamilton County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1980 and offers 4124 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2700, main floor 1424, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Cicero Shores Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located near Morse Lake, a popular lake in the area.

Sr32 or sr38 to hague rd "becomes stringtown pike", north to bayswater, turn left (west) to home.

3 Beds 4 Bath Areas 4124 SqFt

$725,000

(Sold)

CENTURY 21 Scheetz
Time on M.S.Woods: 234 Days
Close [x]
Name this search: 
 
Page 1 of 1



The REALTOR® list, pend and sale information is updated twice per hour from the Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®.