Cottage Home, Indianapolis Homes for Sale

Cottage Home Historic District is located just east of downtown, in the 700 block of Dorman St. and 1100 block of East and Clair Sts. The neighborhood takes its name from the many Victorian, cottage-style homes built between 1870 and 1900. It's a fun community well known for its annual fall Block Party and bi-annual Home & Garden Tour.

Never miss a new listing in Cottage Home!

Latest Cottage Home, Indianapolis Homes for Sale

1323 N Polk Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

1323 N Polk Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Cottage Home at it's best! This home is your ideal entry point to one of the darling neighborhoods of Downtown Indy. Built in 2006, this 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath house si...

5 Beds 4 Bath Areas 2360 SqFt


Everhart Studio, Ltd.
949 N Stillwell Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

949 N Stillwell Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Better than a townhouse (no HOA!) compact SINGLE FAMILY in Cottage Home! 2017 Built, stylish & on trend with everything you need and nothing you don't. Efficiently d...

2 Beds 3 Bath Areas 1520 SqFt


RE/MAX Ability Plus
1724 N Rosette Way, Indianapolis, IN 46202

1724 N Rosette Way, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Home is under construction! The photos are renderings or of similar models. Terrific views from the private rooftop patio. Live the city life with close proximit...

2 Beds 3 Bath Areas 1825 SqFt


Onyx and East, LLC
1122 E 9th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

1122 E 9th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46202

Built in 1872, This is one of the most important Houses in the Cottage Home Neighborhood. Long term ownership spared it from the decline typical of most homes downto...

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2822 SqFt


Front Porch Real Estate, LLC

Return to "Homes for Sale in Indianapolis Historic Districts"

The community is dominated by "worker housing," typified by spindlework porches, turned posts, gable ornaments, variegated and fishscale shingling, and gingerbread trim. Landowners began building here in the 1860s, shortly after the Bellefontaine Railroad built repair shops nearby. Later, the Indianapolis Street Railway built a trolley barn in the neighborhood, providing jobs for operators, conductors, and mechanics, as did veneer and furniture factories on Dorman St., and a flour mill on Highland Ave.

Frederick Ruskaup built a successful (brick) grocery store at 713-715 Dorman in 1875. His earnings from that and several rental properties he owned enabled him to hire well-known architects Vonnegut & Bohn to design a series of two-story shotgun doubles at 702-716 Dorman. Recent owners have restored several of these doubles, which feature hip roofs and full-width porches with lathe-turned posts. In 1890, Ruskaup again hired Vonnegut & Bohn to design his Queen Anne/German Renaissance Revival home at 711 Dorman.

The area was originally part of two large farms owned by (Governor) Noah Noble and Robert Hanna. When the railroad reached Indianapolis in 1847, the city's boundaries pushed out beyond the "Mile Square." The farms were annexed to the City of Indianapolis in 1870.

Among early residents of the neighborhood was Louisa Magruder, daughter of Tom Magruder, the slave of Gov. Noble who is said to be the inspiration for the timeless classic, "Uncle Tom's Cabin."

The Dorman Street Saloon has served for years as a popular neighborhood meeting place and watering hole. Originally built as a house in the early 1870s, the corner building served as a grocery store before being converted to a bar in the late 1910s. It's since been known as Anacker's 9th Street Tavern, The Mahogany Bar, and May's Lounge. A popular rumor claims that infamous criminal John Dillinger frequented the saloon while preparing for his heist of the Massachusetts Avenue State Bank.

Today, some of the original brick sidewalks and limestone curbs still line the streets of Cottage Home, and are cherished by the neighborhood as important features of the historic district. Brick sidewalks remain on portions of Highland Avenue and Dorman Street, including in front of the Ruskaup-Ratcliffe house and store, while limestone curbs can still be found on portions of Highland Avenue, Dorman Street, Stillwell Street, and Oriental Street.