Below are all of the homes in Forest Hills subdivision/neighborhood, Indianapolis, Indiana currently for sale, pending or sold within the last 6 months.

Enter your email address in the yellow box below if you would like to receive an automated email that will update you every time any central Indiana REALTOR® at any real estate company lists, pends or sells a home in Forest Hills.

Forest Hills Homes for Sale & Sold in Indianapolis

Close [x]
Name this search: 
 
 
5826 W Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5826 W Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Located in the highly desirable forest hills neighborhood, this 1934 english tudor beauty is full of charm. This handsome home offers a wonderful office located in the tudor style turret that flows nicely into the kitchen, open to the back living room with a beautiful view of the back yard. When it comes to entertaining this home has so many great options, from the open kitchen, to the backyard/basketball court, and finished basement. Master features its own workout space/possible nursery, balcony overlooking backyard. Master bath that has an amazing whirlpool tub and walk-in closet. The monon trail is right across the street along with walking distance to the redline and canterbury park. Come see all this home has to offer.

MLS/BLC #21791627 is a 6-bedroom, 5-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1934 and offers 5838 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 4231, main floor 2345, basement 1607 and 550 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

East of college avenue on kessler blvd e dr. Turn south on winthrop to 5826 winthrop avenue.

6 Beds 5 Bath Areas 5838 SqFt

$899,900

(Home for Sale)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 46 Days
5737 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5737 N College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Beautiful all brick charmer located in desirable and historic forest hills. Thoughtful consideration was made with every improvement and renovation to preserve the character and charm this home has always offered, while meeting the demands and preferences of todays discerning buyers. Main floor offers formal dining room, huge living room, 2 bed/1 full bath (updated), newer windows, updated on trend kitchen, and sunroom. The backyard is perfect for both entertaining as well as quiet relaxation. Basement is bright and open, withs tons of space and flexibility. Walk able to several areas, and a short bike ride to so much more-the proximity of this location offers incredible convenience for those who prefer to leave the car at home.

MLS/BLC #21800191 is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1930 and offers 2480 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1240, main floor 1240, basement 1240 and 240 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sale Pending"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

From e 56th street, turn right onto kessler boulevard e dr. Turn left onto n college avenue. Home is on your left.

2 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2480 SqFt

$325,000

(Sale Pending)

Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
Time on M.S.Woods: 8 Days
5805 E Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5805 E Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

You will not want to miss a rare opportunity to live in this beautiful forest hills home. This home have been meticulously maintained and updated in the past few years. Located in the heart of forest hills, this home has a great location on a corner lot with mature trees and well manicured lawn and landscaping. This home boasts a new kitchen, updated bathrooms, walk in closet, new flooring in the sunroom and much more. A truly beautiful home.

MLS/BLC #21799580 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1925 and offers 2966 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2108, main floor 1082, basement 858 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sale Pending"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

Go east on 58th st from college to carrollton. Home is on the northeast corner of 58th st and carrollton. Home located in forest hills.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 2966 SqFt

$599,900

(Sale Pending)

Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
Time on M.S.Woods: 14 Days
5728 N Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5728 N Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Stunning all brick charmer in highly desirable historic forest hills district. Walk to nearby amenities, attractions and the red line. A welcoming front porch and charming awning greets you as you approach this home. Enter to fresh paint and stunning hardwood floors. An expansive living room includes a cozy fireplace, wood beams, and built ins. The impressive kitchen includes modern cabinetry, solid surface counter tops, and stainless appliances all included. Large bedrooms include impressive closet space and a recently remodeled upper level bath with stunning finishes. Plenty of bonus and storage space in the finished basement and large four seasons room with new carpet. Enjoy your lush landscaping from your private patio.

MLS/BLC #21783167 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1938 and offers 3803 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2596, main floor 1389, basement 1207 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

Go to kessler boulevard east of college avenue- south on winthrop avenue to home.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3803 SqFt

$555,000

(Sold)

Berkshire Hathaway Home
Time on M.S.Woods: 58 Days
5745 E Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5745 E Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Must see. . Charming english country style cape cod in the heart of the historic forest hills-one of indy’s most desirable nghbrhds. This 3 bd 1. 5 ba features tons of character. Natural light w/ neutral tones, original hdwds thru out, leaded windows, slate roof, large dr w/beautiful chandelier, spacious formal living rm w/ fireplace & french doors leading to sc porch & private backyd. Upper level incl lrg master br w/frpl & dual w-i-c. Basement, great for storage & workout space. Two car detached garage. Location is perfect. . Walking distance to the monon trail, local eateries, shopping, and so much more.

MLS/BLC #21779492 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1930 and offers 2958 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1972, main floor 1972, basement 986 and 360 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

Kessler blvd east from college to guilford. South on guilford to home on left.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2958 SqFt

$500,000

(Sold)

Keller Williams Indy Metro NE
Time on M.S.Woods: 100 Days
936 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

936 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Fabulous forest hills. 1st floor has a lovely foyer leading to the large living room with fireplace, separate sunroom w/stunning original woodwork, dining room & full bath. Updated kitchen w/generous eat in area has french doors to the fenced in back yard. Upstairs, the master has updated en-suite bath w/fireplace, walk-in closet, & separate shower & jacuzzi tub. Two more bedrooms upstairs share an updated hall bath, plus a perfect office nook. New roof in 2019, newer furnace/ac, whole house water softener/ro system & water heater. Large yard w/tigerwood deck & fireplace. New 2-car garage has a large, 2nd floor living/entertainment space w/its own heating & cooling. Home has been inspected and repairs made - receipts/report are available.

MLS/BLC #21770545 is a 3-bedroom, 4-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1940 and offers 2891 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2051, main floor 1211, basement 840 and 504 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

From kessler blvd & college ave, go south to 58th st, left (east) on to 58th st. Third house on the left after guilford ave.

3 Beds 4 Bath Areas 2891 SqFt

$536,000

(Sold)

RE/MAX Ability Plus
Time on M.S.Woods: 113 Days
5821 W Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5821 W Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Property was available for sale by owner. Listed and sold in blc for comparable and appraisal purposes.

MLS/BLC #21773370 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1929 and offers 3467 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2286, main floor 1181, basement 1181 and 320 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

East on kessler blvd from college ave. South on guilford ave to property on your left (east side of street). Home sits on the point where guilford ave and forest lane meet.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3467 SqFt

$550,000

(Sold)

Non-BLC Office
Time on M.S.Woods: 134 Days
818 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

818 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Great new price on this forest hills classic american 4-sqaure with a twist. An impossible-to-find 5 bed, 2 full/2 half ba, att 3 car gar brick home. Gorgeous formal living & dining w/many orig features, updated kitchen, 1/2 bath & home office - main lvl. Stunning wdwrk & hardwd flrs. Finished lwr lvl boasts a family/game rm w/wet bar, 1/2 ba, storage closet/pantry & huge laundry/utility rm. Upstairs offers private master suite w/huge full ba, walk-in closet, & dbl sinks. 4 addtional bdrms (one at the back is used for 2nd home office/tv rm), & hallway full ba. New exterior paint, gutters & guards. Dual system heating/cooling (gas furnace/ac new in 2020). Walk to restaurants, shopping, broadripple & the red line. Center for inquiry 84 & ips

MLS/BLC #21764567 is a 5-bedroom, 4-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1935 and offers 3980 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2900, main floor 1101, basement 1080 and 698 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

Located in exquisite forest hills - college ave to 58th street - east on 58th st to home on the north side of the street.

5 Beds 4 Bath Areas 3980 SqFt

$760,000

(Sold)

Plat Collective
Time on M.S.Woods: 177 Days
908 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

908 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Welcome home to this beautifully kept forest hills charmer. Remodeled w/ great attention to detail while keeping original charm. Main floor fts a circular floor plan w/ formal living, sun room/office, formal dining room, cozy family room & kitchen. Updated kitchen opens to dr for easy entertainment. Ss appliances, built-in refrigerator, bar top seating & granite countertops w/ modern backsplash. Upstairs w/ master suite & 3 additional bedrooms - master includes wic, en-suite w/ dbl sinks, separate tub & tiled shower. Br 2 w/ modern en-suite while br3 & 4 share jack-n-jill bathroom. Finished ll rec room for additional living space. Fully fenced backyard space is pinterest worthy w/ large patio & pergola. Loads of privacy & space to entertain

MLS/BLC #21763387 is a 4-bedroom, 4-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1938 and offers 3611 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2664, main floor 1230, basement 947 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

From kessler and college ave, south on college to 58th st, left(east)on 58th st to home on left.

4 Beds 4 Bath Areas 3611 SqFt

$764,900

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 185 Days
5872 Forest Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5872 Forest Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Step inside this classic forest hills beauty with modern updates. Rare find with main floor laundry/mud room that has been completely remodeled. Large family room and attached garage. Beautiful original details throughout this home. 3 gas fireplaces. Updated master suite & exquisitely updated kitchen. (cambria stone counters, amish inset cabinets, kitchen-aid app) large family room with fireplace, built-ins and beautiful vaulted ceilings. Large, finished basement w/fp (rough plumbing in place for 1/2 bath). Large formal living room with elegant fp. $150k in improvements in 2020: gutted and remodeled kitchen and lndry/mud room, refinished hardwoods, gated drive, all new interior paint, etc. See list for all updates. Ext photos from fall 2020

MLS/BLC #21762975 is a 4-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1931 and offers 3797 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2821, main floor 1845, basement 0 and 420 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

From college & kessler blvd: go 1/4 mile east on kessler to light at forest lane. Turn right (south) on forest lane to 4th house on right (west).

4 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3797 SqFt

$775,000

(Sold)

Elite Indy Realty Group
Time on M.S.Woods: 188 Days
5675 N Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5675 N Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Charming remodeled tudor in forest hills beckons you to stay awhile. Traditional & modern elements blend to create a classic & welcoming home, with a warm comfortable feel. Featuring wood floors, crisp tile, and fixtures you have come to expect in a new custom home. Open living area allows for plenty of natural light, kitchen features a center island with an abundance of storage & large walk-in pantry. Owner's bedroom features a soaking tub, dual showers, dual toilet rooms, and 2 custom walk-in closets with safe & shoe storage. Upstairs and downstairs laundry rooms with 3 bedrooms. Carriage house with private entrance over 2 car garage features 1 bed/1 bath and laundry. Backyard sits on the monon trail for all the local amenities.

MLS/BLC #21756425 is a 4-bedroom, 5-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1920 and offers 5724 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 4860, main floor 2156, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

Kessler blvd to forest lane. South to winthrop which veers to left (east) then to 5675.

4 Beds 5 Bath Areas 5724 SqFt

$1,010,000

(Sold)

Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
Time on M.S.Woods: 235 Days
5856 E Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5856 E Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Your gorgeous new forest hills home awaits. This lovely tudor home is flooded with originality and charm in one of indy's most sought after neighborhoods. The beautiful tuscan inspired kitchen is only 5yrs old and boasts ss appliances with b/in bar area. Original hardwoods sweep throughout the main floor that hosts two bedrooms, one full bathroom, formal dining, and a light filled 4 seasons room that makes a great home office. Upstairs has another full bathroom and master bedroom with a second fireplace and wainscoting throughout. (don't miss the cedar closet. ) the basement is waterproofed and semi-finished- ready to entertain. The back patio is reminiscent of an english garden and perfect for someone looking for an easy to maintain yard

MLS/BLC #21740350 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1930 and offers 2528 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1920, main floor 1465, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

From kessler and college ave head east to carrollton. South on carrollton. Veer to the left of the 'y'. Home will be on your right.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2528 SqFt

$372,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 309 Days
Close [x]
Name this search: 
 
Page 1 of 1



The REALTOR® list, pend and sale information is updated twice per hour from the Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®.