Below are all of the homes in Forest Hills subdivision/neighborhood, Indianapolis, Indiana currently for sale, pending or sold within the last 6 months.

Enter your email address in the yellow box below if you would like to receive an automated email that will update you every time any central Indiana REALTOR® at any real estate company lists, pends or sells a home in Forest Hills.

Forest Hills Homes for Sale & Sold in Indianapolis

Close [x]
Name this search: 
 
 

818 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Great new price on this forest hills classic american 4-sqaure with a twist. An impossible-to-find 5 bed, 2 full/2 half ba, att 3 car gar brick home. Gorgeous formal living & dining w/many orig features, updated kitchen, 1/2 bath & home office - main lvl. Stunning wdwrk & hardwd flrs. Finished lwr lvl boasts a family/game rm w/wet bar, 1/2 ba, storage closet/pantry & huge laundry/utility rm. Upstairs offers private master suite w/huge full ba, walk-in closet, & dbl sinks. 4 addtional bdrms (one at the back is used for 2nd home office/tv rm), & hallway full ba. New exterior paint, gutters & guards. Dual system heating/cooling (gas furnace/ac new in 2020). Walk to restaurants, shopping, broadripple & the red line. Center for inquiry 84 & ips

MLS/BLC #21764567 is a 5-bedroom, 4-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1935 and offers 3980 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

5 Beds 4 Bath Areas 3980 SqFt

$779,999

(Home for Sale)

Plat Collective
Time on M.S.Woods: 30 Days
5675 W Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5675 W Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Charming remodeled tudor beckons you to stay a while. Traditional & modern elements blend to create a classic & welcoming home, with a warm comfortable feel. Featuring wood floors, crisp tile, marble and fixtures you have come to expect in a new custom home. Open living area allows for plenty of natural light, kitchen features a center island kitchen w/ an abundance of storage & large walk-in pantry. Owner’s bdrm features a soaking tub, dual showers, dual toilet rooms & two walk in closets. Upstairs lndry rm w/ 3 bdrms. Carriage house w/ private entrance over 2 car garage w/ 1 bed 1 bath and lndry. Backyard sits on monon trail, connecting you to local restaurants, craft breweries & countless amenities w/in minutes of this forest hills home.

MLS/BLC #21756425 is a 4-bedroom, 5-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1920 and offers 5724 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

4 Beds 5 Bath Areas 5724 SqFt

$1,100,000

(Home for Sale)

Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
Time on M.S.Woods: 88 Days
5872 E Forest Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5872 E Forest Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Step inside this classic forest hills beauty with modern updates. Rare find with main floor laundry/mud room that has been completely remodeled. Large family room and attached garage. Beautiful original details throughout this home. 3 gas fireplaces. Updated master suite & exquisitely updated kitchen. (cambria stone counters, amish inset cabinets, kitchen-aid app) large family room with fireplace, built-ins and beautiful vaulted ceilings. Large, finished basement w/fp (rough plumbing in place for 1/2 bath). Large formal living room with elegant fp. $150k in improvements in 2020: gutted and remodeled kitchen and lndry/mud room, refinished hardwoods, gated drive, all new interior paint, etc. See list for all updates. Ext photos from fall 2020

MLS/BLC #21762975 is a 4-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1931 and offers 3797 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sale Pending"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

4 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3797 SqFt

$775,000

(Sale Pending)

Elite Indy Realty Group
Time on M.S.Woods: 41 Days
908 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

908 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Welcome home to this beautifully kept forest hills charmer. Remodeled w/ great attention to detail while keeping original charm. Main floor fts a circular floor plan w/ formal living, sun room/office, formal dining room, cozy family room & kitchen. Updated kitchen opens to dr for easy entertainment. Ss appliances, built-in refrigerator, bar top seating & granite countertops w/ modern backsplash. Upstairs w/ master suite & 3 additional bedrooms - master includes wic, en-suite w/ dbl sinks, separate tub & tiled shower. Br 2 w/ modern en-suite while br3 & 4 share jack-n-jill bathroom. Finished ll rec room for additional living space. Fully fenced backyard space is pinterest worthy w/ large patio & pergola. Loads of privacy & space to entertain

MLS/BLC #21763387 is a 4-bedroom, 4-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1938 and offers 3611 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

4 Beds 4 Bath Areas 3611 SqFt

$764,900

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 38 Days
909 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

909 E 58th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Interior photos on sunday. Lovely french cottage on picturesque tree-lined st. In heart of forest hills - one of indy's most desirable nghbrhds. Home has retained its original character w/hdwds thru out, glass knobs, orig bath tile etc. Main flr boasts spac formal lr w/frpl & large bay window. Dr w/original chandelier & french doors opens to 3-season porch. The beaut updated kit w/timeless shaker cabinetry includes wall-mounted tv. 2 sizeable bdrms & full bath complete main fl. Upper level incl lg master w/ 2-room w-i-c, a large 2nd bdrm, and a full bath. Bsmt boasts newly-finished fr w/frpl & pergo flooring, stor rms w/ new epoxy floors & incl work-out area, laundry area, & huge storage area. Back yard incl composite deck and paver patio.

MLS/BLC #21751073 is a 4-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1940 and offers 3720 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

4 Beds 2 Bath Areas 3720 SqFt

$510,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 120 Days
5856 E Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5856 E Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Your gorgeous new forest hills home awaits. This lovely tudor home is flooded with originality and charm in one of indy's most sought after neighborhoods. The beautiful tuscan inspired kitchen is only 5yrs old and boasts ss appliances with b/in bar area. Original hardwoods sweep throughout the main floor that hosts two bedrooms, one full bathroom, formal dining, and a light filled 4 seasons room that makes a great home office. Upstairs has another full bathroom and master bedroom with a second fireplace and wainscoting throughout. (don't miss the cedar closet. ) the basement is waterproofed and semi-finished- ready to entertain. The back patio is reminiscent of an english garden and perfect for someone looking for an easy to maintain yard

MLS/BLC #21740350 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1930 and offers 2528 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2528 SqFt

$372,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 162 Days
5885 N Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5885 N Guilford Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Nicely updated mid-century ranch in forest hills is just waiting for you. Tons of space with 3 beds on the main floor plus additional non-conforming bed/den in the finished basement. Expansive kitchen w/ ss appliances, granite counters, custom cabinets, breakfast bar and dining nook makes for easy entertaining. Lots of natural light throughout. 3 full baths, 2 wood burning fireplaces, newly extended patio with hot tub and more.

MLS/BLC #21739579 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1953 and offers 3493 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3493 SqFt

$444,000

(Sold)

Highgarden Real Estate
Time on M.S.Woods: 164 Days
5845 E Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5845 E Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Forest hills, prime location. Home features 4 bedroom, 3 bath. Freshly painted, updated kitchen, marble counter tops, s. S. Appliances, travertine tile, new cabinets. Basement features egress windows, full bath, new vinyl flooring, closets, built in shelving and second washer and dryer. Bedroom 3 could be second master.

MLS/BLC #21731251 is a 4-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1947 and offers 2596 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

4 Beds 3 Bath Areas 2596 SqFt

$421,500

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 199 Days
934 E 57th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

934 E 57th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Welcome home to this beautiful 3 bedroom 2. 5 bathroom home in coveted forest hills. You will love the natural hardwood floors and main concept living space. The updated kitchen features stainless steel appliances, is connected to the eat-in kitchen and large family room, and is a perfect place for family gatherings. The two sided stone fireplace is the focal point of the family room, but also connects to the gorgeous sun room that leads out to a large deck. Upstairs is a master suite with a large, updated bathroom, jacuzzi tub and built in blue tooth speaker/exhaust fan, an additional living space and walk-in closet. This home is close to everything broad ripple has to offer and is just across the street from the monon trail.

MLS/BLC #21732138 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1926 and offers 3810 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3810 SqFt

$370,000

(Sold)

F.C. Tucker Company
Time on M.S.Woods: 199 Days
5886 Forest Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5886 Forest Lane, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Location+style. . This classic tudor boasts one of the largest and most versatile yards in forest hills with layered back patio perfect for entertaining. The interior features a fully updated kitchen and master bath, lots of light and neutral tones throughout with rare, thin-slat hardwood floors. Walking distance to the monon and evening strolls through historic forest hills make this a true lifestyle home. You don't want to miss this one.

MLS/BLC #21728056 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1935 and offers 3181 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3181 SqFt

$450,000

(Sold)

Highgarden Real Estate
Time on M.S.Woods: 220 Days
5699 N Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5699 N Winthrop Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Don't miss this updated, 3-bedrm home on double lot in exclusive forest hills and backs up to the monon trail w/ private access. Open family rm w/ newer gas log fireplace insert (2016). Dining rm w/ custom built-ins. Hardwoods throughout. 2nd bedrm on main w/ half bath. New water softener (2019). Updated eat-in kitchen w/ white cabinets & newer appliances (2018/2019). New flooring in kt & main level bath (2020). Master bedrm w/ double closets. Newer roof, gas tank-less water heater, & hvac (2016). Unfinished basement offers additional living space & storage. Enjoy your private, fenced-in backyard oasis w/ deck & open patio space for entertaining. Mins from shops, entertainment, & restaurants. This gem will not last long.

MLS/BLC #21715909 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1930 and offers 2700 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2700 SqFt

$420,000

(Sold)

Keller Williams Indpls Metro N
Time on M.S.Woods: 225 Days
5675 W Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

5675 W Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220

Subdivision: Forest Hills

Add to Favorites

Forest hills: walkable-monon trail, commutable-red line, convenient, turnkey english cottage, 3 br, 3 full ba, so much character without sacrificing comfort. Foyer, lr w/beamed cath ceiling, frplc, built-ins & window seat. Sep dr w/beamed ceiling & fr doors. Seasonal glass enclosed porch w/vaulted beamed ceiling-potential conversion to use year 'round. Custom kit w/bf bar. 2 main level brs & full ba. The half story contains the mbr suite w/sitting area, huge ba w/double shower & vanity, walk-in closet. Noteworthy: completely re-landscaped, irrigated yard, ag walk, paver patio w/firepit, veg garden, privacy fence. Newly finished bsmt fr, laundry & full ba. New 2 car garage-heating, pull down stairs. Just move in & enjoy.

MLS/BLC #21703895 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Marion County, Indiana. This Residential/Condo was built in 1935 and offers 3651 square feet of total space. The current listing status is "Sold"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.
This property is conveniently located in Forest Hills, a popular Indianapolis-area neighborhood.
This property is conveniently located within walking distance of Monon Trail, a popular trail in the area.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3651 SqFt

$530,000

(Sold)

Berkshire Hathaway Home
Time on M.S.Woods: 332 Days
Close [x]
Name this search: 
 
Page 1 of 1



The REALTOR® list, pend and sale information is updated twice per hour from the Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®.