Homes for Sale in New Castle, Indiana

2009 W Plum Street, New Castle, IN 47362

4br/1ba home. Step in from the covered front porch. Main-lvl has living room, eat-in kitchen w/breakfast bar, br's 2, 3 & 4 (br 4 currently used as dining rm) & full bath. Upper level is the master bedroom. Unfinished basement w/laundry area. Partially covered deck in the privacy fenced backyard. Roof 6 yrs old. 2-car detached garage. Move in and call home.

MLS/BLC #21810877 is a 4-bedroom, 1-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1900 and offers 1986 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1444, main floor 1084, basement 542 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"

From junction of hwy 3 and us 38, go east on 38 (broad st) to 18th st/103 and turn south. Continue to plum st and turn east. Home will be on south side of street.

4 Beds 1 Bath Areas 1986 SqFt

205 N 17th Street, New Castle, IN 47362

Updated and move- in ready home offering 2 bedrooms and 1. 5 bathrooms with a full basement. This beautiful home will make a great space for your family. The updated kitchen provides a full suite of new stainless steel appliances. The decorative fireplace is a show stopper and perfect focal point in the living room. Come and see this home today.

MLS/BLC #21814320 is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1946 and offers 2304 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1728, main floor 1152, basement 576 and 264 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Martin L. Powell's Add Subdivision.

State 38/broad st to 17th st. North to house.

2 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2304 SqFt

1305 S 21st Street, New Castle, IN 47362

This 3 br home offers lots of living space, enclosed front porch/sunroom, high ceilings and spacious bedrooms. On the main floor you will find a large living room open to the dining room and kitchen. 1 bedroom on the main floor, full bath and laundry hookups. On the second floor, you will find a large landing area with 2 spacious bedrooms.

MLS/BLC #21814312 is a 3-bedroom, 1-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1930 and offers 1760 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1584, main floor 880, basement 176 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

From sr 3/38: s on sr 3 to parkview dr. E on parkview dr to bundy ave. Ne on bundy ave to i ave. E on i ave to s 14th st, n on 14th st to i ave. E on i ave to s 21st st. N on s 21st st to property.

3 Beds 1 Bath Areas 1760 SqFt

8390 E County Road 300, New Castle, IN 47362

Great 3 bedroom 1. 5 bath ranch located on 4 acres. Living room has great natural lighting with a beautiful view. Kitchen and family room are open concept, with a stone fireplace in the family room. All 3 bedrooms are good sized, with a bonus room that currently serves as an office. Large breezeway connects the home to the 2 car garage. Breezeway can serve as mudroom, allow for extra storage, and so much more. Outside you will find a pole barn, 3 sided haybarn, and 2 chicken coops that stay with the property. So much to love about this calm country setting. Property is being sold as-is.

MLS/BLC #21814110 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1972 and offers 2250 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2250, main floor 2250, basement 0 and 825 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

St rd 38/wilbur wright rd, south on wilbur wright rd to 300 s. East on 300 s to property.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2250 SqFt

2021 W Lake Forest Lane, New Castle, IN 47362

This 3 or 4 br, 2. 5 bath home is ready for you to move in and make it your own. Large yard, covered front porch and open deck in back give plenty of areas to enjoy this quiet neighborhood. Walking distance to elementary school, park and walking trails. Kitchen has a breakfast bar and is open to dining area. Master br with walk in closet and full bath, 2nd br, laundry with half bath all on main level. Large br with walk in closet, full bath, and extra room that could be another bedroom or playroom on upper level. Roof only a year old, newer furnace and water heater. Easy commute to muncie or anderson.

MLS/BLC #21814073 is a 4-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 2001 and offers 2288 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2288, main floor 2288, basement 0 and 504 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

Sr 3 and 38 north on sr 3 to garner st. East to 14th st. South on 14th to washington st. East on washington to 20th st. North on 20th to lake forest lane. East to property.

4 Beds 3 Bath Areas 2288 SqFt

914 S 18th Street, New Castle, IN 47362

Victorian cottage with lots of updates, 2, bedroom 1 bath, fenced yard. New flooring, new furnace, newly painted/primed, new drywall in the living room, new bath, newly insulated, back porch, new countertop in kitchen, new range oven, detached garage

MLS/BLC #21813034 is a 2-bedroom, 1-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1900 and offers 1240 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 940, main floor 940, basement 300 and 336 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the First Industrial Subdivision.

From st rd 3 and st rd 38 drive east on st rd 30 (broad street) to 18th street turn south to property

2 Beds 1 Bath Areas 1240 SqFt

39* Nw Prairie Knoll Drive, New Castle, IN 47362

Picturesque corner residential lot perfect for your new dream home in the growing prairie knoll neighborhood. Will make a special place to call home. Country living with the city advantages. Mt. Summit corporation limits. Convenient location making commuting to indy, muncie, anderson, and richmond easy. Paved streets and curbs. City utilities including sewer. Storm water system. Restrictive covenants.

MLS/BLC #21813402 is a 0-bedroom, 0-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. The current listing status of this land is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Prairie Knoll Subdivision.

From sr3/36 take sr36 west to walnut, turn right to high street, turn left to split, turn to the left and lots are on the corner of hill run and rolling meadows.

0 Beds 0 Bath Areas 0 SqFt

38* Nw Prairie Knoll Drive, New Castle, IN 47362

Picturesque corner residential lot perfect for your new dream home in the growing prairie knoll neighborhood. Will make a special place to call home. Country living with the city advantages. Mt. Summit corporation limits. Convenient location making commuting to indy, muncie, anderson, and richmond easy. Paved streets and curbs. City utilities including sewer. Storm water system. Restrictive covenants.

MLS/BLC #21813400 is a 0-bedroom, 0-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. The current listing status of this land is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Prairie Knoll Subdivision.

From sr3/36 take sr 36 west to walnut, turn right to high st. Turn left and take high street to the split, go left to corner of hill run and rolling meadows. Lot is in the corner.

0 Beds 0 Bath Areas 0 SqFt

3** Nw High Street, New Castle, IN 47361

Large picturesque residential lot perfect for your new dream home in the growing prairie knoll neighborhood. Will make a special place to call home. Country living with the city advantages. Mt. Summit corporation limits. Convenient location making commuting to indy, muncie, anderson, and richmond easy. Paved streets and curbs. City utilities including sewer. Storm water system. Restrictive covenants.

MLS/BLC #21813396 is a 0-bedroom, 0-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. The current listing status of this land is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Prairie Knoll Subdivision.

From sr3/36 take sr 36 west to walnut, turn right and take to high street, turn left and take to first lot on left

0 Beds 0 Bath Areas 0 SqFt

2** Nw High Street, New Castle, IN 47361

Large picturesque residential lot perfect for your new dream home in the growing prairie knoll neighborhood. Will make a special place to call home. Country living with the city advantages. Mt. Summit corporation limits. Convenient location making commuting to indy, muncie, anderson, and richmond easy. Paved streets and curbs. City utilities including sewer. Storm water system. Restrictive covenants.

MLS/BLC #21813393 is a 0-bedroom, 0-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. The current listing status of this land is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Prairie Knoll Subdivision.

From sr3/36 take sr 36 west to walnut, turn right to high street and take to second lot on the left.

0 Beds 0 Bath Areas 0 SqFt

1** Nw High Street, New Castle, IN 47362

Large picturesque residential lot perfect for your new dream home in the growing prairie knoll neighborhood. Will make a special place to call home. Country living with the city advantages. Mt. Summit corporation limits. Convenient location making commuting to indy, muncie, anderson, and richmond easy. Paved streets and curbs. City utilities including sewer. Storm water system. Restrictive covenants.

MLS/BLC #21813388 is a 0-bedroom, 0-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. The current listing status of this land is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Prairie Knoll Subdivision.

From sr3/36 take sr 36 west to walnut, turn right to high street, turn left to property on right.

0 Beds 0 Bath Areas 0 SqFt

4115 S Memorial Drive, New Castle, IN 47362

Here is your rental investment opportunity. There are 3 homes on this property, the information on listing sheet pertains to main home. Information of other two houses available in supplements. Rent on grey house is $800 per month and is currently rented with a great tenant, little home is $600 per month. Both of those homes are on same gas meter, and gas is included in the rent. A beautiful property in new castle, with mature trees and plenty of yard space. Main home has beautiful double sided fireplace, and large kitchen with big windows overlooking backyard. Large three car garage and big master bedroom. All three homes make this a unique property with a lot of character.

MLS/BLC #21812663 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1959 and offers 2961 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2655, main floor 2655, basement 1991 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

2nd property north of walmart in new castle, on the west side of south memorial drive.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2961 SqFt

1608 W Bundy Avenue, New Castle, IN 47362

Two large living ares in the living and family rooms. 2 bed 2 bath with over 1700 square feet. Screened porch overlooks the large yard with beautiful park like setting.

MLS/BLC #21812546 is a 2-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1958 and offers 1746 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1746, main floor 1746, basement 0 and 462 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Forest Hills Subdivision.

I-70 to sr 3 to new castle. Turn on bundy avenue to address.

2 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1746 SqFt

1320 E Us Highway 36, New Castle, IN 47362

Exquisite property and home just 45 minutes from indianapolis. This unique home sits on over 20 rolling acres overlooking a private, crescent shaped, 5 acre lake that is stocked and has a dock and 2 islands. Estate comes with a private guest house with heat and a/c, shiplap walls, scraped oak flooring, and french doors overlooking the lake. Also included is a 3 story, historic 1800s gable barn that is perfect for a workshop or farm animals, next to a charming caretaker's residence. Recently remodeled, the extra large custom kitchen features a brazilian hardwood barrel ceiling with designer cabinets and liqueur/coffee bar. See associated docs for further details.

MLS/BLC #21811376 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1960 and offers 2916 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1720, main floor 1720, basement 1196 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

From sr 3and 38: north on sr 3 to us hwy 36. East to property on north side of road.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2916 SqFt

812 E Stewart Drive, New Castle, IN 47362

Look at this. This home has received a brand new roof, along with some new gutters. Many areas of the home have been repainted and had new carpeting installed. The inside is fully handicap accessible. Home is situated on a corner lot with many mature trees and has a full circle drive to make access easy. The backyard includes a large, inviting patio. It is ready for you to move in and make yourself at home.

MLS/BLC #21810314 is a 4-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1955 and offers 2016 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2016, main floor 2016, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Forest Subdivision.

I-70/sr 3. North on 3 to parkview, east to bundy, north to stewart turn east to property.

4 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2016 SqFt

712 N County Road 500, New Castle, IN 47362

This is a fantastic opportunity to own a small farm homestead and if you’re looking to do organic, this place already has 14 acres that are certified and ready. The large 5 bed, 2. 5 bath farmhouse has a newer roof and the character is just incredible. The property also features a detached 2 car garage, a 600 sq ft shop, 2800 sq ft horse barn with 6 stalls, 500 sq ft greenhouse, a newly renovated 500 sq ft chicken house, and brand new fiber optic internet is ready for you at the road. The property is partially fenced and is ready for you to do virtually anything including farming, gardening, equestrian, cattle, 4-h, hay, or anything else.

MLS/BLC #21809712 is a 5-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1875 and offers 3535 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 3535, main floor 2192, basement 0 and 880 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

Map from address

5 Beds 3 Bath Areas 3535 SqFt

1349 W Short Street, New Castle, IN 47362

2 bedroom, 1 bath home. Close to amenities. Laundry room on main level.

MLS/BLC #21808434 is a 2-bedroom, 1-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1900 and offers 900 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 900, main floor 900, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Speeder Cycle Subdivision.

South on 14th street to short street. West on short street to home on south side of road.

2 Beds 1 Bath Areas 900 SqFt

1223 E Bundy Court, New Castle, IN 47362

Remodeled within the last few years, this home is up to date and move-in ready. The kitchen, bathrooms, flooring and cabinets were are done in the remodel. 3br/1. 5ba with just over 1350 sqft, open kitchen with breakfast bar, dining room and very large living room with a fireplace. 1/2 bath off the dining room on the main floor. Upstairs is the large primary bedroom that has a generous sized closet with sliding barn doors, plus 2 more bedrooms and the full bath. Craftsman style doors, trim and hardware are found throughout the whole home. There is a privacy fence in the back yard with access to the detached garage and full basement. Stove, refrigerator, washer and dryer remain with the home.

MLS/BLC #21808415 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1925 and offers 2028 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1352, main floor 676, basement 676 and 190 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

From sr3/38 take 38 east to main street, take main south to bundy ct, turn right to property on left.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 2028 SqFt

1010 S 15th Street, New Castle, IN 47362

Find this 3 bedroom, 1. 5 bath tucked away on a quiet street. It features fully updated kitchen & bathrooms, a master bedroom with attached full bath, original hardwood flooring, large bedrooms, main floor laundry hook-up, and a detached garage. Hvac, plumbing, and electrical updated in 2016.

MLS/BLC #21806417 is a 3-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1900 and offers 1296 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1296, main floor 816, basement 0 and 352 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

South on state rd 3 to indiana ave. East on indiana ave to 14th street. South on 14th st to c ave. East on c ave to 15th st. South on 15th to property on eastside.

3 Beds 2 Bath Areas 1296 SqFt

221 S 24th Street, New Castle, IN 47362

Fixer upper. Located on large corner lot off broad street in eastwood elementary area.

MLS/BLC #21806233 is a 2-bedroom, 1-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1900 and offers 2730 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1365, main floor 1365, basement 1365 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Mikel & Ogborns Coble Subdivision.

Broad to 24th. South to property on west side.

2 Beds 1 Bath Areas 2730 SqFt

0-0a E Cindy Lane, New Castle, IN 47362

The proposed build is located on lots 24 and 25 of tabor trails. They are located at the end of sandy gale ave. At the t on cindy lane. Don't miss your opportunity to build your dream home in this great are of new castle, in. This is one of the last few lots in tabor trails. The subdivision is south of the down town area and has convenient access to i-70. This davis home proposed build offers the hamilton elevation a classic collection (see attached info) upgrades available upon request. Lot cost is $17,800 for both. Site costs are $45,000 with an upgrade allowance of $10,000 and a future price increase allowance of $5,000. Water is available for a $825 tap feeplus approval from the utility impact board.

MLS/BLC #21803846 is a 3-bedroom, 3-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 2021 and offers 1822 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 1822, main floor 911, basement 0 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the Tabor Trails Subdivision.

From indianapolis, in take i-70 east to hwy 3 north to sandy gale ave. And turn right to the lots. They are located at the end of sandy gale (at the t in the road) or cindy lane. Lots are at the t on the r.

3 Beds 3 Bath Areas 1822 SqFt

1000 E Indiana Avenue, New Castle, IN 47362

Totally updated interior. Quality work throughout with new flooring, paint, kitchen, bathrooms, & lights. Move in condition. Day of closing possession.

MLS/BLC #21803250 is a 4-bedroom, 2-bath property located in Henry County, Indiana. This Home was built in 1900 and offers 3328 square feet of total space as follows: upper floor 2144, main floor 1184, basement 1184 and 0 sq. ft. in the garage. The current listing status is "For Sale"
This listing is in the No Subdivision Subdivision.

3 & 38 - south on 3 to indiana, east on indiana, property on north side. Enter and park on the back side of house.

4 Beds 2 Bath Areas 3328 SqFt