Cicero Real Estate

Cicero Real Estate

Welcome to Cicero, Indiana – a charming lakeside town nestled in the heart of Hamilton County! Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Cicero offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With its serene setting along the banks of Morse Reservoir, residents enjoy a variety of outdoor recreational activities, from fishing and boating to hiking and picnicking in the lush parks.

Cicero is more than just a beautiful backdrop; it boasts a vibrant local culture. The town hosts numerous community events throughout the year, including the popular Cicero Community Festival, where families come together to celebrate with live music, delicious food, and engaging activities for all ages. The historic downtown area is dotted with quaint shops, cozy cafes, and unique eateries, making it an ideal spot for leisurely strolls and delightful discoveries.

Education is a cornerstone of the Cicero community, with access to top-rated schools that prioritize academic excellence and personal growth. Families can feel confident that their children are receiving a quality education in a supportive environment.

Cicero's strategic location also provides easy access to nearby cities like Noblesville and Fishers, as well as the vibrant metropolis of Indianapolis, allowing residents to enjoy the best of both worlds. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful retreat or an active lifestyle, Cicero, Indiana, is a hidden gem that promises a welcoming atmosphere and a bright future. Come and discover the warmth and charm that make Cicero a wonderful place to call home!

Newest Listings in Cicero

339 W Cass Street, Cicero
$200,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
**UNBEATABLE LOCATION IN THE HEART OF CICERO!** Bring your vision and imagination to this fixer-upper loaded with potential! Situated on a spacious lot with a large fenced backyard and oversized detached one-car garage, this property offers plenty of possibilities. Inside, you'll find a huge 21x16 family room, a spacious eat-in kitchen with a charming breakfast nook, and a generous 10x5 foyer featuring two large closets for additional storage. The enclosed breezeway offers a convenient laundry area with washer and dryer and access to the backyard. But the real standout is the location! Enjoy small-town living within walking distance of downtown Cicero's popular restaurants, shops, and local favorites, including Boathouse Kitchen & Swan Dive, DeLullo's Trattoria, 10 West and more! Morse Reservoir is one block away, adding to the charm of this wonderful lake town. Whether you're an investor, renovator, or buyer looking to make a home your own, this is a fantastic opportunity to create something special in a location that's hard to beat! Home has been an investment property and to be sold in "as is" condition. Schedule your showing today!

339 W Cass Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Suzi Leidenfrost. Real Broker, LLC
34 Blue Water Drive, Cicero
$399,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
ON THE WATER! Vacation year round with beautiful water views on Morse Reservoir under $400K! Affordable living meets lake life in this spotless 2 bed 2 bath manufactured home that has new lights, new carpet and fresh paint throughout. Enjoy your morning coffee on the screened porch with expansive views of the water. Your private BOAT DOCK is just steps outside the back door. Large storage shed is perfect for yard tools and boating gear. This little gem is conveniently located a short golf cart ride across the bridge to tons of shops, restaurants, grocery store and more! Enjoy easy, waterfront living in the quaint town of Cicero!

34 Blue Water Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Jennifer Deakyne. F.C. Tucker Company
Timberline Drive, Cicero
$25,000

Timberline Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Dustin Kelly. Trueblood Real Estate
141 Sunset Court, Cicero
$235,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This home is ready for you to move right into. Fresh paint, refinished deck & Spacious rooms. Large kitchen with lots of cabinets, as well as counter space & an island. Stainless steel appliances and a new washer & dryer. All the bedrooms have walk in closets. Bathrooms have tile floors. Spacious primary bedroom with private bath w/ garden tub & separate shower. Enjoy your evenings on the back deck. Detached 2 car garage. Fenced yard. Great location, close to school, shopping, etc. Close to the heart of Cicero, numerous golf courses and Morse Lake. Cicero is a golf course community as well.

141 Sunset Court, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Lisa Kercheval Aerne. F.C. Tucker Company
2020 Treving Drive, Cicero
$374,990
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Located close to Morse Reservoir, you will enjoy trips to Wolfie's, The Boathouse, Alexander's, Morse Beach and Park, and the cutest Ace hardware in Hamilton County. This FRESHLY PAINTED SHOJI WHITE open-concept home is waiting for you. The kitchen is designed with a new Island that includes custom cabinetry below, well-coordinated quartz countertops, a quartz composite kitchen sink, seating for 4, while being open to the Family Room. The front room can be used as a formal dining room, living room, office, or playroom. The covered front porch and large backyard are waiting for you to enjoy. The newly poured concrete patio is ready for you to add a sunroom. (Footers were poured under half of the patio). Walk upstairs to 3 large bedrooms, a large loft, and a conveniently located laundry room. Greystone Village offers a playground and access to Cicero's walking/bike path. Renovations include: Interior paint and trim, LVP waterproof flooring, carpet, canned lighting and chandelier, entry shiplap wall, microwave, dishwasher, washer, dryer, hvac, roof,. All kitchen appliances are included.

2020 Treving Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Lori Flynn. CENTURY 21 Scheetz
61 Hickory Ridge Circle, Cicero
$1,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
There are lakefront homes, and then there are properties that would be nearly impossible to recreate. Set on approximately 1.74 acres on a point along the main body of Morse Reservoir, 61 Hickory Ridge Circle offers an extraordinary 400+ feet of shoreline-one of the largest private shorelines on the reservoir. The property was made for life on the water, with a private dock and boat lift, an attached boat garage, and a PRIVATE BOAT RAMP-believed to be the only one on Morse (deeded and grandfathered). Inside, a dramatic floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace anchors the main living area beneath soaring vaulted wood ceilings, while expansive windows keep the lake in view. In fact, every bedroom and living space enjoys water views, even the kitchen sink. The main-level primary suite includes a private office, while the walkout lower level offers three additional bedrooms, a recreation/living area with wood stove, and direct access to the pool patio. Outside, a main-level deck overlooks the in-ground pool, lawn and water beyond, creating an incredible setting for entertaining or simply spending a summer day at home. A three-car attached garage, turnaround drive, metal-shingle roof, whole-home diesel generator and in-ground propane tank serving the pool heater add practical amenities to an already remarkable property. Tucked at the end of a quiet circle with Bear Slide Golf Course just across the road from the neighborhood, you're also a short boat ride from some of Morse Reservoir's favorite waterfront destinations. Homes can be updated and styles can change, but more than 400 feet of shoreline on a main-body point like this simply can't be recreated.

61 Hickory Ridge Circle, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Alan Hamson. Real Broker, LLC
1140 Frogs Leap Lane, Cicero
$289,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Enjoy easy living near Morse Reservoir in this beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch in desirable Warehams Pond! The open floor plan connects a stylish kitchen featuring granite countertops, a beautiful backsplash, breakfast bar, and included appliances to a spacious great room with soaring cathedral ceilings-perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The privately situated primary suite offers a walk-in closet and a spacious bath with double sinks, a garden tub, and separate shower. Two additional bedrooms provide room for guests, family, or a home office. Step outside to enjoy the new patio and fenced backyard, with yard space extending beyond the fence. Updates completed within the last five years include HVAC, windows, garage door, patio, carpet, dishwasher, and light fixtures. An attached 2-car garage completes this inviting home!

1140 Frogs Leap Lane, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Kaye Simmons. Hardie Group
999 Shoreline Circle, Cicero
$374,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
WELCOME HOME to the desirable lakeside town of Cicero! Tucked away on a peaceful cul-de-sac just a stone's throw from Morse Lake, this beautifully updated ranch offers the perfect combination of space, flexibility and lake-town living. Walk-or take your golf cart-to the park, library and Alexander's, and enjoy the sights and sounds of the lake right from home! This RARE FIND features 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, an unfinished basement for great dry storage, and TWO PRIMARY SUITES-perfect for guests, multi-generational living or a variety of living arrangements. The spacious main primary suite offers a large sitting room ideal for a home office, walk-in closet with laundry, and generous bath with double sinks, walk-in shower and Jacuzzi tub. The second suite includes its own full bath and private deck access. The vaulted great room features soaring ceilings and a brick-hearth wood-burning fireplace, while the split floor plan provides added privacy. Extensively updated and truly move-in ready! Recent improvements include nearly all new LVP flooring, Craftsman-style interior doors and trim, fresh interior paint, updated lighting and plumbing fixtures, dishwasher and water heater. Major 2026 improvements include a BRAND-NEW DECK, new garage door and opener with upgraded hardware and windows, new driveway with sidewalk, additional parking and GOLF CART PARKING PAD, professional-grade water softener, sump pump with battery backup and new back door with built-in blinds. Roof, windows and Hardie plank siding were replaced in 2021. Enjoy easy, low-maintenance living near Morse Lake and top-rated Hamilton Heights Schools. Nothing to do but move in and start enjoying life by the lake!

999 Shoreline Circle, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Ann Dashiell. CENTURY 21 Scheetz
169 W Buckeye Street, Cicero
$379,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Your Private Backyard Oasis in the Heart of Downtown Cicero! This charming 4-bedroom home blends historic character with modern updates and features an exceptional outdoor retreat! Enjoy a heated in-ground pool with sun deck, automatic cover and vacuum, plus a gazebo (2024) and spacious backyard perfect for entertaining, grilling or relaxing. Inside, you'll find a desirable main-level owner's bedroom with walk-in closet, updated bath with Jacuzzi-brand whirlpool tub, and remodeled kitchen (2023) featuring a built-in beverage bar. Updated lighting throughout adds a fresh, modern touch. Recent improvements include 8 new windows (2025), furnace and A/C (2024), electric water heater (2025), storage shed (2025), water softener and reverse osmosis system (2022). Roof professionally inspected in 2026. Conveniently located near downtown festivals, community events, waterfront dining and Red Bridge Park, with SR 19 just one block away. Enjoy small-town charm, modern comforts and resort-style outdoor living!

169 W Buckeye Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Brenda Cook. F.C. Tucker Company
2429 Cape Henry Court, Cicero
$1,100,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Main-body Morse Reservoir ranch with beautiful sunset views and walkout basement! This spacious ranch offers 2 bedrooms and 2 full baths on the main level, plus 3 additional bedrooms and a full bath in the walkout lower level. A newer addition features a new bedroom and full bath along with a convenient second laundry space. The main level is designed to take advantage of the lake views, with a vaulted great room featuring lake-friendly luxury vinyl plank flooring and a gas fireplace, all open to the kitchen and overlooking the water. The lower level offers a second living space and walks directly out to the covered porch and lake. Outside, there's tons of space to relax and entertain with newer composite decking and incredible western sunset views. The dock setup is ready for all your lake toys with a composite dock, 2 metal-roof covered slips, a 6,600-lb HydroHoist lift, 2 jet ski ports and a newer seawall. Enjoy main-body Morse Lake living with a spacious ranch floor plan, all tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac just minutes from quaint downtown Cicero!

2429 Cape Henry Court, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Andy Sheets. Compass Indiana, LLC
1220 Shoreline Drive, Cicero
$1,250,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Located on Morse Reservoir in desirable Cicero Shores, this remodeled and lovingly maintained 3-bedroom, 3.5-bath waterfront home is packed with features! With brand-new flooring, fresh paint, new lighting, beautiful cabinetry, and top-of-the-line new appliances, this home is truly move-in ready. Outside, you'll find your very own Lake Life Starter Package! Included with the home are a tritoon boat, boat trailer, 2 boat lifts, 2 additional boat slips, dual jet ski lift, and jet ski trailer-everything you need to start enjoying lake life from day one. Multiple decks overlook the water, while the enclosed patio creates the perfect space to relax and entertain. Step inside to a beautifully updated interior with a welcoming living space and gorgeous finishes throughout. The main level features a bedroom and separate full bath, perfect for guests or convenient main-level living. The remodeled kitchen offers brand-new cabinetry, top-of-the-line appliances, updated lighting, and plenty of style. Upstairs, you'll find a private guest suite with its own full bath, thoughtfully separated from the primary suite. The spacious primary suite features a beautiful new private deck overlooking the water, a custom walk-in closet, and a private bath complete with both a stand-up shower and relaxing garden tub the perfect place to unwind after a day on the lake. The walk-out basement is a clean slate, ready for you to create your dream lake-house hangout, theater, gym, or additional living space. The massive 3-car garage offers plenty of room for vehicles and lake toys and even includes a convenient half bath. This is more than a home it's the Lake Life Starter Package you've been waiting for, complete with waterfront living, boats, lake toys, and room to make it your own!

1220 Shoreline Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Kelly Smotherman. White Stag Realty, LLC
129 W Neal Street, Cicero
$199,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Charming 2-Bedroom Home in the Heart of Cicero! Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom single-family home, ideally located just minutes from all that downtown Cicero has to offer. From the moment you arrive, you'll be greeted by a quaint covered front porch. Step inside to a welcoming living room featuring neutral paint and durable LVP flooring that flows throughout the home. The functional eat-in kitchen offers ample bright white cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and plenty of space for everyday meals and entertaining. Just off the kitchen is a convenient laundry/utility room complete with a washer and dryer combo. Down the hall, you'll find two nicely sized bedrooms and a full bathroom with a tub/shower combination. Outside, enjoy the fully fenced backyard, offering space for pets, play, gardening, or simply relaxing outdoors. A storage shed with power provides convenient additional space for tools, equipment, and hobbies. Located just minutes from Morse Reservoir, local dining, shops, and the small-town charm Cicero is known for, this home offers convenience, comfort, and character. Whether you're looking for a cozy primary residence or an investment opportunity, this charming home checks all the boxes!

129 W Neal Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Rosie Berzenye. T&H Realty Services, Inc.
Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!