Cicero Homes with Unfinished Basement

Welcome to Cicero, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hamilton County! This charming town offers a delightful combination of small-town charm and modern conveniences, making it an ideal destination for families, retirees, and anyone looking to enjoy a peaceful lifestyle. With its picturesque lakes, lush parks, and friendly community, Cicero is a place where neighbors become friends and memories are made.

Cicero is known for its rich history and vibrant culture, with plenty of local events and festivals throughout the year that bring the community together. The town is conveniently located just a short drive from Indianapolis, providing easy access to the city’s bustling attractions while allowing residents to return to the tranquility of their hometown. Whether you enjoy boating on Morse Reservoir, exploring scenic trails, or indulging in local dining, Cicero has something for everyone.

For those looking to find their dream home, Cicero offers a variety of properties, including homes with unfinished basements. These versatile spaces provide endless possibilities for customization and expansion, allowing you to create the perfect recreational area, home office, or additional living space tailored to your needs. Imagine the potential of transforming an unfinished basement into your personal sanctuary, complete with a cozy media room or a vibrant play area for the kids.

With its welcoming atmosphere and beautiful surroundings, Cicero is not just a place to live; it's a place to thrive. Explore the opportunities that await you in this delightful town and discover why Cicero, Indiana, is the perfect place to call home!

Newest Cicero Homes with Unfinished Basement

$200,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

**UNBEATABLE LOCATION IN THE HEART OF CICERO!** Bring your vision and imagination to this fixer-upper loaded with potential! Situated on a spacious lot with a large fenced backyard and oversized detached one-car garage, this property offers plenty of possibilities. Inside, you'll find a huge 21x16 family room, a spacious eat-in kitchen with a charming breakfast nook, and a generous 10x5 foyer featuring two large closets for additional storage. The enclosed breezeway offers a convenient laundry area with washer and dryer and access to the backyard. But the real standout is the location! Enjoy small-town living within walking distance of downtown Cicero's popular restaurants, shops, and local favorites, including Boathouse Kitchen & Swan Dive, DeLullo's Trattoria, 10 West and more! Morse Reservoir is one block away, adding to the charm of this wonderful lake town. Whether you're an investor, renovator, or buyer looking to make a home your own, this is a fantastic opportunity to create something special in a location that's hard to beat! Home has been an investment property and to be sold in "as is" condition. Schedule your showing today!

339 W Cass Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Suzi Leidenfrost. Real Broker, LLC

$369,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Your Private Backyard Oasis in the Heart of Downtown Cicero! This charming 4-bedroom home blends historic character with modern updates and features an exceptional outdoor retreat! Enjoy a heated in-ground pool with sun deck, automatic cover and vacuum, plus a gazebo (2024) and spacious backyard perfect for entertaining, grilling or relaxing. Inside, you'll find a desirable main-level owner's bedroom with walk-in closet, updated bath with Jacuzzi-brand whirlpool tub, and remodeled kitchen (2023) featuring a built-in beverage bar. Updated lighting throughout adds a fresh, modern touch. Recent improvements include 8 new windows (2025), furnace and A/C (2024), electric water heater (2025), storage shed (2025), water softener and reverse osmosis system (2022). Roof professionally inspected in 2026. Conveniently located near downtown festivals, community events, waterfront dining and Red Bridge Park, with SR 19 just one block away. Enjoy small-town charm, modern comforts and resort-style outdoor living!

169 W Buckeye Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Brenda Cook. F.C. Tucker Company

$1,250,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Located on Morse Reservoir in desirable Cicero Shores, this remodeled and lovingly maintained 3-bedroom, 3.5-bath waterfront home is packed with features! With brand-new flooring, fresh paint, new lighting, beautiful cabinetry, and top-of-the-line new appliances, this home is truly move-in ready. Outside, you'll find your very own Lake Life Starter Package! Included with the home are a tritoon boat, boat trailer, 2 boat lifts, 2 additional boat slips, dual jet ski lift, and jet ski trailer-everything you need to start enjoying lake life from day one. Multiple decks overlook the water, while the enclosed patio creates the perfect space to relax and entertain. Step inside to a beautifully updated interior with a welcoming living space and gorgeous finishes throughout. The main level features a bedroom and separate full bath, perfect for guests or convenient main-level living. The remodeled kitchen offers brand-new cabinetry, top-of-the-line appliances, updated lighting, and plenty of style. Upstairs, you'll find a private guest suite with its own full bath, thoughtfully separated from the primary suite. The spacious primary suite features a beautiful new private deck overlooking the water, a custom walk-in closet, and a private bath complete with both a stand-up shower and relaxing garden tub the perfect place to unwind after a day on the lake. The walk-out basement is a clean slate, ready for you to create your dream lake-house hangout, theater, gym, or additional living space. The massive 3-car garage offers plenty of room for vehicles and lake toys and even includes a convenient half bath. This is more than a home it's the Lake Life Starter Package you've been waiting for, complete with waterfront living, boats, lake toys, and room to make it your own!

1220 Shoreline Drive, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Kelly Smotherman. White Stag Realty, LLC

$329,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome to this charming ranch nestled in the heart of downtown Cicero, where timeless character meets everyday comfort & exceptional versatility. Whether you're searching for your next investment opportunity or the perfect place to put down roots, this inviting home offers the best of both worlds! Inside, you'll discover beautiful original hardwood floors that flow throughout the living room, dining room, & two secondary bedrooms. The primary bedroom features updated luxury vinyl plank flooring, while elegant arched doorways & a built-in dining room cupboard add warmth and classic character throughout the home. An unfinished basement provides endless possibilities for additional storage, a workshop, or future expansion. Step outside & fall in love with the outdoor spaces. Relax year-round in the enclosed patio porch-the perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee, or unwind with an evening book! The fully fenced, generously sized backyard provides plenty of room for pets, play, gardening, or weekend gatherings! The 2-car garage & additional storage shed offer ample space for vehicles, tools, hobbies, & outdoor equipment. Adding even more value, the current owners have successfully utilized this property as an income-producing rental, & it is currently tenant occupied, demonstrating its appeal as a desirable rental property. Whether you're a seasoned investor looking to expand your portfolio, a first-time investor seeking a property with established rental history, or a buyer searching for a place to proudly call home, this property presents exceptional flexibility to fit your goals. Best of all, there's NO HOA, giving you the freedom to truly make this property your own! Whether you're looking for a investment, a weekend retreat, or your forever home, this property offers charm, flexibility, and an unbeatable location in one of Hamilton County's most welcoming lakeside communities!

230 S Peru Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Tamara Venable. Compass Indiana, LLC

$699,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover a unique opportunity at 9510 E 235th ST, CICERO, IN. This single-family residence, built in 1948 and totally remodeled 22 years ago. It offers 2677 square feet of living space on a generous 5 acre (217,800 square foot) lot. It is country living at it's finest, close to town and Morse reservoir. This one-story property presents a distinctive canvas for creating your ideal living environment. Wonderful living room with woodburning fireplace. Formal dining room with built in cabinets, for those wonderful holiday meals. New Microwave/oven and refrigerator in the last 3-5 years. Attic and basement for great storage. Main bedroom has the attached office or sitting room, which could also be used as a 3rd bedroom. Recreation room is attached to the house by the breezeway, and is large enough that it could be made into a 3rd or 4th large bedroom. This expansive property invites you to envision a life of comfort and personal expression. Large barn great for storage and multiple other uses. It also has an attached, enclosed parking spot for a 5th wheel, or multiple cars, with sliding doors to drive straight thru. Home also features a private shooting range and a grain bin with a large smiley face. The small grain bin has an enclosed 150 gallon fuel tank. Explore the possibilities and schedule your private viewing today to fully appreciate the potential of this compelling property.

9510 E 235th Street, Cicero

Listing courtesy of Linda Babbitt. Gold Key Properties

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.

Cicero Homes with Unfinished Basement

Newest Cicero Homes with Unfinished Basement

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?